
Welcome
Custom Sweets
Questions via text only to 513-265-1185.
Orders require pre-payment 1 week in advance of the pick up date.

Questions via text only to 513-265-1185.
Orders require pre-payment 1 week in advance of the pick up date.
Made from scratch and designed to steal the spotlight.

Custom sugar cookies made to match your special event perfectly! Each set is handcrafted from scratch and decorated with detailed royal icing designs tailored to your theme, colors, and style.

Delicate, buttery tea cookies with a light, melt-in-your-mouth texture and a sweet icing center. Available in classic Vanilla or Almond — simple, elegant, and perfect for showers, parties, holidays, or everyday treats.

Our cookie cakes are the perfect centerpiece for graduations, birthdays, corporate celebrations, and special events. Made with a soft, bakery-style cookie base and decorated with buttercream and custom themed details, each cake is personalized to match your celebration. Available in a variety of sizes.
Sizes:
12 inch round - $25 (serves 8-10)
Mini cookie cake cups - $30 (2 dozen)
1/2 sheet -$60 (serves 20-30)

Perfect for weddings, corporate events, dessert tables, and special gatherings, our handcrafted mini desserts are made from scratch and beautifully presented for easy serving. Choose from classic favorites, elegant filled cookies, and rich brownie trays — perfect for creating a memorable sweet table for your guests.
Mini cookies are sold by the 4 dozen minimum per flavor. Select flavors may be substituted with 2 dozen large cookies. Brownies are available by the pan and serve up to 24 guests.

Cake Sizes:
6 inch - serves 8 ($40)
8 inch - serves 16 ($60)
10 inch - serves 28 ($80)
12 inch- serves 40 ($100)
Standard Cakes are 2 layers and includes writing/florals/borders.
(Additional cost for cake images)

Cake Sizes:
6 inch - serves 14
8 inch - serves 24
10 inch - serves 38
12 inch- serves 53
All sizes are 3 layers. Option for 4 layers.
Most cakes are decorated with custom cookies.

Available sizes per tier:
5 inch - serves up to 6
6 inch - serves 14
8 inch - serves 24
10 inch - serves 38
12 inch- serves 53
14 inch - serves 74

Smash Cake
5 inch cake - serves up to 6
*Discounted if ordering other baked goods.

1/4 sheet - serves 24 - $40
1/2 sheet - serves 48 - $80
Full sheet - serves 96 $160
*Additional cost for images, themes, and fillings.

Cupcakes - Starting at $30/dozen
Mini Cupcakes - Starting at $15/dozen
Optional: Mini cookie toppers on regular size cupcakes - $1.00 each

Chocolate
White
Yellow
Confetti
Marble (Chocolate & White)
Lemon
Strawberry
Red Velvet
Carrot Cake

Chocolate (no additional charge)
Peanut Butter (no additional charge)
Cookie Butter - Additional charge
Strawberry - Additional charge
Raspberry - Additional charge
Lemon Curd - Additional charge
Blueberry - Additional charge
*Sample cake boxes available for weddings. Submit an order form with up to 3 flavor profiles.
Exciting news! 🎉
We now have dye-free color options available, and this is just the beginning. As new dye-free colors are launched, We’ll be adding more to the lineup.
If you’re looking for cleaner options without sacrificing color, keep an eye out—more coming soon! 💛
At Broken Egg Bakery, we believe that every bite tells a story. Our journey began with a passion for baking and a commitment to using only the finest ingredients, ensuring that each treat is made with love and care.
We are a cottage food bakery located in Wayne Township, Butler County, Ohio at the Jacksonburg & 73 intersection.
Delivery available in limited areas.
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.